Comparing smoking to bacon in terms of risk of cancer is
extremely misleading, despite the strength of evidence being similar.
Vegetarians are probably breathing a sigh of relief today as
headlines are warning us that processed and cured meats cause cancer. But the
way this message has been framed in the media is extremely misleading.
Comparing meat to tobacco, as most news organisations who’ve
chosen to report this have done, makes it seem like a bacon sandwich might be
just as harmful as a cigarette. This is absolutely not the case.
 |
| A bacon sandwich |
The headlines are referring to the news that the World
Health Organisation has classified cured and processed meats (bacon, salami,
sausages, ham) as group 1 carcinogens, because there is a causal link between
consuming these meats and bowel cancer. This group also includes tobacco,
alcohol, arsenic and asbestos, all known to cause certain cancers.
But just because all these things cause cancer, doesn’t mean
they’re all as risky as each other. A substance can increase your risk of
cancer a small amount, or, like tobacco, a huge amount. Comparing them like for
like is just really confusing to anyone trying to work out how to lead a
healthy life.
The risk of lung cancer from smoking is extremely high. Of
all cases of lung cancer (44,488 new cases in the UK in 2012), evidence
suggests that 86% of these are caused by tobacco. And lung cancer isn’t the
only type of cancer caused by smoking. CRUK estimate that 19% of all cancers
are caused by smoking. Another way of looking at this is that if smoking was
completely eliminated, there would be 64,500 fewer cases of cancer in the UK
per year.
In contrast, the recent evidence that suggests a causal link
between processed meat and bowel cancer estimates that 21% of bowel cancers
(which occurs at slightly lower rates than lung cancer – 41,600 new cases in
2011) were caused by eating processed and red meat. If all such meat was
eliminated entirely from our diet, they estimate that 8,800 cases of cancer
would be prevented in the UK per year.
All this simplistic reporting ignores a variety of other
factors – the amount you consume, for example, is likely to affect your risk a
great deal. And that’s not to mention addiction – however much you crave a
bacon sandwich at times, it doesn’t contain nicotine.
The WHO have deemed the strength of evidence that processed
meats cause cancer to be equivalent to that showing that smoking causes cancer.
This means that if you eat a lot of red or processed meats you are increasing
your risk of cancer. But to compare it to something as lethal as smoking is
confusing and dangerous.
For more information visit:-
